A report by the New Zealand Initiative finds that civil servants are more likely to vote for left-wing parties and questions if the public service can be relied on to give ministers candid advice and carry out their decisions.
The report found a pronounced leftward voting skew among policy analysts and advisers, who reported voting 60% for the left bloc and 34% for the right in 2023. Among current public servants surveyed overall, 45% reported voting for each bloc.
Furthermore, about 70% agreed with the statement “the public service serves the public, not the elected government”. Some 62% supported framing advice to steer a minister away from a predicted decision, while 55% suggested briefing outside groups and the media as a way to make an unwanted policy politically untenable. That rose to nearly two-thirds among managers and leaders.
Overall, the share of agencies meeting their own targets for advice quality fell from about 80% in 2020/21 to just over 50% in 2024/25.
Interviewees also described instances when they encouraged delays in process, watered-down policies before they reached ministers and outright refused to do what ministers ordered them to do, but their accounts did not say how often these interferences occurred.
The report pointed to two tests to check for possible public service bias:
Could ministers hear expert advice directly before it was watered down by bureaucrats? And once ministers made a decision, could they count on officials to carry it out even when they disagreed? If the answers were negative for both or either of these tests, bias might be a factor in official advice.
The survey used a six-point scale without a neutral option and measured attitudes. The authors added 23 statements to seven national polls run by Curia Market Research and posed them to 380 serving and 338 former public servants. The researchers also interviewed 40 people, including ministers, advisers and senior officials, while examining agency performance reviews.
This story has been republished with permission from RCR Bites. For news like this direct and free to your Inbox every day, go to biteme.news to sign up for RCR Bites.
If you are a media outlet interested in republishing RCR Bites stories, please contact inbox@rcr.media.