The British government has been compelled to confirm that it secretly instructed Apple to provide access to encrypted customer information after a London tribunal rejected its attempt to prevent disclosure of the surveillance directive.
The Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruled on Thursday that the Home Office had failed to establish that revealing the existence of the order would threaten national security. Issued under the Investigatory Powers Act, the technical capability notice reportedly required Apple to enable access to encrypted iCloud backups belonging to users worldwide.
Apple challenged the demand and subsequently withdrew its Advanced Data Protection service from the UK, maintaining that it would not compromise customer security by creating encryption backdoors.
The original directive, reportedly issued in January 2025, triggered tensions with Washington over potential access to American citizens’ private data and was later withdrawn following discussions between British and US officials. A second, more limited notice targeting UK users was reportedly issued in July 2026, prompting further legal action by Apple.
Privacy campaigners Liberty and Privacy International welcomed the tribunal’s decision as an important step towards greater government transparency. However, the legality of the surveillance requirements remains unresolved, with further hearings anticipated in 2027. The precise technical obligations imposed on Apple have not been publicly disclosed.